"Centralization
of credit in the banks of the state, by means of a national bank
with state capital and an exclusive monopoly."
~ Fifth plank of the Communist Manifesto, 1848
Statists have long prized and fueled crisis as the means for
enlarging government. They convince enough people that the
federal government never does wrong, yet the evil that lurks in
the world will on occasion strike us. Sometimes the evil
is external, as in 9-11, other times it is internal, as in the
case of certain economic upheavals. When the crisis is
mostly economic, the culprit is always the private sector, and
the guilty parties are usually big shots who got swept away with
avarice. With a lapdog media clamoring for
"reform," politicians pass more laws and flood the
airwaves with rhetoric about how their new legislation will
crush the forces of greed.
It was crisis that helped launch one of the greatest destroyers
of our world, the Federal Reserve System.
In the era following the War of Secession, the federal
government aggressively promoted development of the West through
huge subsidies and other favors to business cronies. Corruption
flourished, and overextended banks occasionally failed, causing
panics in 1873, 1884, 1893, and 1907. Throughout this era
there was growing opposition to sound money, eloquently
expressed by railroad speculator Jay Cooke in 1869:
"Why," he asked, "should this Grand and Glorious
country be stunted and dwarfed--its activities chilled and its
very life blood curdled by these miserable 'hard coin'
theories--the musty theories of a bygone age." [1]
The Panic of 1907 is especially significant because it led to
government-directed banking "reform." The panic
got underway when United Copper's stock price collapsed. Knickerbocker
Trust of New York had invested heavily in United Copper, and
depositors made a run on the bank to get their money out. When
Knickerbocker failed, depositors at other banks got nervous and
demanded their money, igniting the panic. [2]
J. P. Morgan got together with other banking leaders and met
virtually nonstop for three weeks to solve the crisis. They
secured credit from foreign investors, redirected funds from
strong banks to weak ones, and bought stock in foundering but
still promising companies. [3] The panic died a few
weeks later.
For the New York bankers, however, there remained a much more
serious problem. The growth of state banks over the
previous 20 years had slowly eroded their power. By 1896,
state and other nonnational banks constituted 61% of the total,
and by 1913, 71%. More significantly, nonnationals
commanded 57% of banking resources by 1913. [4]
With such a troubling trend, what did the New York bankers do?
They turned to their pals in Washington. As we've
seen, from the time of Lincoln's administration government
sought to partner with business, delivering special favors in
return for political support. This is mercantilism, the
system we rejected in 1776. By the early 20th century, we
were neck-deep in Progressive propaganda, and there was no
viable group opposing government takeover of our lives. The
once laissez-faire, sound-money Democratic Party died with the
nomination of William Jennings Bryant for president in 1896.
From that point on, Republicans and Democrats alike were
promoting more statism as the miracle cure for ills it had
breeded.
Both Congress and the American Banking Association had been
pushing for central banking since the 1890s. The Panic of
1907 gave them another excuse to make it a reality. Amid
all the maneuvering and proposals for fundamental change, Morgan
banker Henry Davison organized a duck hunting trip at Jekyll
Island, Georgia in December, 1910. The ducks they took aim
at were not the web-footed kind, but the unsuspecting American
citizen who had always thought of money as gold.
The hunters were major players in American mercantilism: Senator
Nelson Aldrich (R., R.I.), who had headed up the National
Monetary Commission, a congressional committee dedicated to
developing ideas for central banking; Frank Vanderlip of
Rockefeller's National City Bank; Paul Warburg of the investment
firm of Kuhn, Loeb, & Co., who was there to promote the
German central bank of Bismarck; Charles Norton of First
National Bank of New York, a Morgan company; and Davison, a
partner of J.P. Morgan's. [5]
They devised a plan whereby a board of commercial bankers would
supervise regional reserve banks. When Aldrich later
introduced it to Congress, Democrats blocked it. In 1913,
Carter Glass, a Democratic congressman from Virginia, used the
Jekyll Island scheme as the basis for the Federal Reserve Act.
[6]
The Act created 12 regional reserve banks ruled by a board of
Washington bureaucrats, including the Treasury secretary and
presidential appointees. Though the reserve banks are
officially "private" institutions, they're little
different than government agencies, as Murray Rothbard noted.
In this manner government seized what Rothbard called "a
crucial command post" of the economy, and therefore of the
American society. [7] It used crisis--repeated
panics created by government meddling--and the economic
illiteracy and trust of the public to achieve its purpose.
And what has it sown from its command post? A subtle means
of wealth transfer. A method of taxing us without
legislation. A way of counterfeiting money legally. "Through
the purchase of [usually government] debt by a bank, fiat money
is injected into the economy," Gary North writes. [8]
"Wealth then moves to those market participants who
gain early access to this newly created fiat money," who
are usually politically connected. The ones on fixed incomes or
without close government connections are the losers, as the
injection of money eventually jacks up prices.
The Fed greatly reduced reserve requirements during the 1920s,
expanding credit recklessly and generating a false prosperity
that ended in the crash of 1929. People knew what the Fed
was up to--manufacturing dollars out of thin air--and started a
run on banks to pull their money out in the form of gold specie
and certificates. When Roosevelt took office, he slammed
the bank door in their faces, then later ordered them to return
their gold. In 1933 he made the dollar a fiat currency
domestically, but backed by gold internationally.
Roosevelt also created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
(FDIC) in 1933, providing federal guarantee of bank deposits.
Bank runs and the threat thereof have vanished, and most
people believe this is good. As Lew Rockwell observes, the
threat of bank runs used to "to keep wanton investing at
bay," but the government-banking cartel views such
restrictions "as against the national interest. As a
result, the [banking] industry is perpetually shaky, and the
largest banks are a menace to public life itself." [9]
Prior to 1929 the government had never intervened to help
recovery from a recession. Previous administrations had
let recessions run their course, and recovery, at the hands of
the market, usually occurred in a year or less. Hoover,
and then Roosevelt to a much greater degree, took the statist
course and drove the economy into a prolonged depression. For
his part, Roosevelt has been deified.
The Fed, as the engine of inflation, bankrolls government
wrong-doing. Its creation marked the first step in the
destruction of sound money--our gold standard. As Ludwig
von Mises wrote long ago, "Ideologically, [sound money]
belongs in the same class with political constitutions and bills
of rights." [10] In the name of civil liberty
and civilization itself, the Fed should be abolished.
References
1. The Mystery of Banking, Murray Rothbard, New York:
Richardson and Snyder, 1983. p. 135. (PDF version)
2. Separating Money and the State, Part I: Eighty Years of
Destruction, Douglas E. French, http://www.fff.org/freedom/1094e.asp
3. The Panic of 1907 and the Birth of the Federal Reserve,
Jim Klann, http://www.lp.org/lpnews/0108/klann.html
4. Rothbard, p. 136
5. Rothbard, p. 137
6. French
7. Taking Money Back, Murray Rothbard, http://www.lewrockwell.com/rothbard/tmb.html
8. Gary North, in Forward to Rothbard's Mystery of Banking
9. Banks on the Dole, Llewellyn H. Rockwell, http://www.mises.org/freemarket_detail.asp?control=216&sortorder=articledate
10. The Theory of Money and Credit, Ludwig von Mises, Yale
University Press, 1953,
p. 414